Mendota Mdewakanton Dakota Tribe to again seek federal recognition.
Article by Jenna Kunze. Aug 2nd, 2021
MENDOTA, Minn. — At the confluence of the Minnesota and Mississippi Rivers in the heart of the Twin Cities exists the Mendota Mdewakanton Dakota Tribal Community (MMDTC), a 125-member group who can trace their ancestry in the area back to the mid 1700s.
But because of issues stemming from the U.S.-Dakota conflict in 1862 when the federal government dissolved treaties with the Dakotas and drove most of them out of the state, MMDTC says it has been dispossessed of its land and federal tribal status.
Now, for the second time in 25 years, the Mendota Mdewakanton — a word to describe a number of Eastern Dakota or Sioux people — is seeking federal acknowledgement from the U.S. Department of the Interior.
“It’s very important,” said Chairwoman Sharon Lennartson, 74, who has led the MMDTC nonprofit entity for a decade and a half after helping the group organize in 1995. “We’ve wanted this since day one when we started our community.”
Like other Mendota Dakota descendants of mixed-blood ancestry coming from the French fur traders, Lennartson grew up out of touch with her Indian heritage.
“I wasn’t raised Native,” she said. “I never got to dance with my aunties and uncles. That was all taken from me.”
In the late 1990s, groups of Mendota families organized to take back their identities. Their awareness came from the nearby Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community, which put an ad in the paper looking for descendants. Lennartson’s grandfather was granted land to farm in Shakopee, and her cousins are enrolled tribal members. But Lennartson and several others didn’t qualify for membership under Shakopee’s bylaws.
“Where we really belong is in Shakopee,” said Richard LeClaire, MMDTC’s oldest member and Lennartson’s cousin. “They wouldn’t let us in. They cast us off and told us to go start your own club. And that’s exactly where we are today.”
Lennartson said the main push behind federal recognition hinges on reclaiming historic properties once belonging to their ancestors, including the DuPuis House where her grandparents once lived. The house is currently owned by the state and operated by the Minnesota Historical Society, which gives MMDTC permission to host monthly meetings there.
Additionally, federal recognition would allow MMDTC to apply for certain federal grants and pools of money to help fund programs, such as Dakota language classes, and the group’s annual powwow.
Mendota historian and MMDTC member Greg Strandmark said he feels confident the tribe will meet the Department of Interior’s seven mandatory criteria to gain federal recognition, despite the tribe’s ill preparedness in the process decades earlier.
The group didn’t follow through on its 1996 petition past the “technical assistance” phase because it didn’t have enough research to make its case to the Department of the Interior’s Office of Federal Acknowledgement, which determines if a petition will move through the process of acknowledgment.
“It was a fairly incomplete petition back then,” Strandmark said.
A technical assistance letter from the Office of Federal Acknowledgements informed the MMDTC at the time that “these materials do not provide an adequate basis on which the (Assistant Secretary – Indian Affairs) could make a determination concerning federal government acknowledgment under all seven criteria.”
However, after several trips to the National Archives in Washington, D.C. and Kansas, plus more information being made available online, the group is ready to submit a petition once again.
Arlinda Locklear, an enrolled member of the Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina and an attorney practicing federal Indian Law for 35 years, said the process of filing a petition presents “a quadruple whammy” for tribes.
The process of meeting all seven criteria requires a “high burden of proof” that necessitates expert analysis, which is expensive especially for resource strapped unrecognized tribes. On top of that, the people who could provide oral testimonies and documentation that might help prove certain criteria for a tribe are aging, Locklear said, noting the federal recognition process can take a generation to complete.
“You have this really awful evidentiary requirement placed upon people with no resources, but at the same time they’re trying to comply with that, they’re losing generations of people who have access to some of that information,” she said. “It’s not uncommon for tribes to spend 20 to 30 years … in the preparation of and in following the processing of these petitions.”
According to Locklear, garnering the extensive documents and expert analysis needed for a strong petition could cost tribes close to $1 million.
For MMDTC, which has existed entirely through volunteers, the petition has cost $500,000 in time and money, according to Strandmark’s estimates.
Challenges from Indian Country
Beyond meeting the onerous criteria from the federal government, the MMDTC also faces challenges from other tribes. To that end, the nearby Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community disputes Mendota’s legitimacy as a tribe.
At the crux of the argument, the Shakopee contend that when Congress bought land for Dakota communities in the 1800s, the Mendota were left out, unlike the other three recognized Dakota communities in Minnesota.
“Land was purchased at Prairie Island, Lower Sioux, and Shakopee,” the community wrote in a statement to Tribal Business News. “Land was never purchased at Mendota. Based upon our understanding of the tribal recognition process, there is no factual basis for a tribe to secure recognized government status at Mendota.”
A letter from a BIA agent to the commissioner in 1888 noted that land wasn’t purchased for the local Native community in Mendota because it was significantly more expensive than what the agency was willing to spend. The cost at “$500 per acre” in Mendota compared to $15 an acre elsewhere, likely because of the proximity to St. Paul and Minneapolis.
Locklear noted that federally recognized tribes can oppose the recognition process of other tribes as a means of self-preservation and staving off competition for gaming ventures in many cases. For the Shakopee specifically, the tribe’s existing casino would inevitably be threatened if the Mendota were to open a casino less than 10 minutes from the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport.
“A lot of recognized tribes have a policy of opposing the recognition of any tribe in their vicinity,” Locklear said. “I’ve seen it in (the) Northwest, I’ve seen it on the east coast. It happens all over the country. It happens when there is potential for gaming competition. It happens when there is potential for participation in a pro-rata share of treaty fishing rights. It happens when there is concern about sharing limited Indian Health Services appropriations.
“A lot of these reasons … relate to there being too little resources on the table in the first place for Native communities.”
Kevin Washburn (Chickasaw Nation of Oklahoma), the former Assistant Secretary of Indian Affairs at the U.S. Department of the Interior and current dean at the University of Iowa College of Law, said that in some cases, the challenges from one tribe group to another goes beyond economic considerations.
“If there was no gaming in the world, I’m not sure that the opposition would go away,” he said. “It goes to the core of identity in some cases.”
Ultimately, MMDTC members expect the road to federal recognition will be a long one. Currently, the BIA has six petitions “in process” that have each been submitted as far back as 1994, with no time limit set for a decision. An additional five potential tribes are in the pipeline once they supplement their petitions.
“Most of these tribes that have gone through federal recognition, they’ve been going through it for decades. It’s generational,” Strandmark said. “If we get federal recognition, I’ll go to the spirit world knowing that 100 years from now, the community will still be there. It won’t be forgotten in history.”
Want more news about the $130 billion tribal economy?
Tribal Business News publishes thoroughly reported and well-crafted stories about Native businesses and entrepreneurs, growth and expansion strategies, best practices, economic data, government policy and other relevant business news. Tribal Business News is required reading for tribal council members and leaders of Native businesses, as well as state and federal legislators, policymakers, economic developers, entrepreneurs, bankers, lawyers and anyone interested in doing business in Indian Country.
Mendota Dakota Mdewakanton Tribal Community Discussion Federal Recognition Meeting Press Release
If the video doesn’t work, or if you prefer to download it, here is the video hosted in Zoom:
Press Release 6/21/2021
Reply to us as to what you think of the video?
Thank you Greg Strandmark Historian and Sharon Lennartson Tribal Chairwoman.
I will add more names of people to thank, soon as I complete the list.
Within this document, I being of legal age, hereby give my consent to have my name enumerated on the census roll of the Mendota Mdewakanton Dakota Tribal Community of the State of Minnesota.
The regulations, paperwork, research and criteria for gaining federal recognition can be exhausting. We could really use your help to do some research with us. If you have time, please contact Perry and he can let you know how you can help. (612) 327-0100
This is 1 page of the BIA criteria for gaining federal recognition.
Click the image to open or if you prefer to download as a PDF click this: 25CFR Part 83 2015 abbreviated PDF
If you would like to read the entire 35 page “Code Of Federal Regulations”, please download here: 25CFR Part 83 2015 35 pages
If you would like to read the entire 913 page “Code Of Federal Regulations” It’s available at the BIA website here: LINK
Hello all members, we are working very hard on Federal Recognition. Here are some new forms for you to fill out. You now have another 30 days from today August 10-2016.Thank you for members who sent in your information. Members need to contact the tribal office to get their files up to date, we donâ€™t have the staff to call everyone. If your paperwork is not complete your name will not go to the OFA when we send it in again. Because if one thing is missing from one member file the whole Mendota file will be set aside for who knows how long. When we get closer we will have 5 members go over all the files to make sure everyone has what the OFA needs.
We need a Certified Birth Certificate. Not a copy of a birth certificate, that has been notarized. We don’t need your original birth certificate.
We will be adding to the website about F.R. as we get more information and you will be getting emails too.
The Federal Recognition Committee
These and other important forms and documents are also available in the DOWNLOADS section.
Hello, my name is Carl Leith
I’ve volunteered to help The Mendota Community attain FederalÂ Acknowledgement.
I have been working with Perry Altendorfer, Mendota Historian
We’ve been meeting about every other Tuesday, for more than 6 months now
In that time the Dept. Of Interior has changed the rules and regulations for recognition.. Btw itâ€™s no longer called federal recognition, now itâ€™s called acknowledgement
Prior to contacting the Mendota Council, I did my own research
This research kept bringing me back to Mendota
My Family descends from Chief Wakute (Redwing)
My father Chris Leith
Grandfather Walter Leith(b.Grey Cloud Island)
Great-Grandmother Sarah (Dow) Leith(Grey Cloud Island, later at Lower Sioux)
Great-Grandfather Frank Lawerence(both at Egglestone,Goodhue Cty, Mn
Anges(Frazier)Lawrence, father was John Frazier
Mother Jennie Frazier, Ages was the youngest daughter
John Frazier’s Father was Joseph Jack Frazier
Joseph Jack Frazier’s Father was a Lt. James Frazier
Lt. James Frazier married Hazzadowin, daughter of Wakute(Redwing)
They are all on every Mdewakanton census ever compiled by any US agent
Last fall the Dept. of Interior changed the regulations for acknowledgment. A person no longer needs to prove descent from a person who signed an aboriginal treaty
But prove descent from a person just going to the 1900’s
I had in my research went back to Wakute
I went back a little further and found Joseph Jack Frazier with his son John on RG75/Roll M550 “the half breed Tract”
Did research on this RollM550
Found out most of these were children of the Traders and Half breed Traders
They had formed kinship ties with the Dakota Chiefs
These Chiefs had signed the aboriginal Treaties of the Mdewakanton Wahpahkute Ppl…Most were in the Employ of Henry Sibley-his first wife was Dakota
Lawrence Taliaferro married a daughter of Cloudman
Bernard W Brisbois – the Indian agent at Prairie du Chein
Married a daughter of Wabasha III
The list goes on and on..
Walter McLeod and his family
Faribaultâ€™s, Renvilles, Labattes,
James McLaughlin’s wife, Mary Buisson
I had contacted Sharon Lennartson, Mendota Tribal chair
If I can help with the acknowledgment
Mendota’s ’92? Application for recognition was returned shortly after the regulation changes…told to re-apply and “tweak” their application a litte bit
So we discussed how to do that
I looked at the membership requirements of the MMDTC constitution
To comply with the new regulations..
We should use Mdewakanton specific Rolls and Census’
Posted in the federal register regarding the Wolfchild I litigation
When they had the public meetings with the BIA, to discuss a plan for distribution
We should be using these lists
The DOI has said was acceptable
“(1) the 1886 McLeod Census
(2) The 1889 Henton Supplemental Census
(3) The 1917 McLaughlin Roll (with additional proof of Mdewakanton descent for persons appearing on that roll)
(4) Certificates assigning 1886 lands we now add to this list of probative documents:
(5) The Birch Cooley Censuses prepared by Robert Henton; and
(6) The 1899 roll prepared by Inspector McLaughlin. These additional rolls also were prepared at the direction of the Secretary of the Interior for the purpose of determining eligibility under the Appropriations Acts.
(If link doesn’t work, try refreshing the page)
The 1917 McLaughlin Roll
This Roll, James McLaughlin had to investigate and find out who didn’t take part in the Dakota War
By Act of March 4h 1917 “An Act to Restore Treaty Annuities, as if the Act of Feb 16th never happened”
The authorities are contained with the 1917 Roll
Henton’s Roll of Birch Cooley and Pipestone Rolls consists of 2 separate Rolls
One for Full Bloods and another for mixed bloods
I would like to add JW Balmers 1934 Pipestone Base Roll
This roll contains ppl who were very young on the Half breed and Mixed blood M550 Roll
On the 1934 Pipestone Base Roll
They are very old now
Carl Robert Leith
Would like more help on this project
Feel free to contact myself or Perry